NEWS

ICTD hosts digital payments discussion at IMF/World Bank Annual Meetings

This article is also available in French

A conference room full of people in professional attire, facing a projected screen upfront.

Researchers from the International Centre for Tax and Development (ICTD) joined policymakers, researchers, and development partners in Bangkok this month, on the sidelines of this year’s IMF/World Bank Annual meetings. ICTD Senior Research Fellow Fabrizio Santoro, who co-leads the Centre’s Digital Public Infrastructure (DPI) and Tax programme, convened a side event on ‘Building cashless economies: Balancing inclusion, formalisation and state capacity’.

The event tackled the opportunities and challenges presented by cashless payments as they become central to economic digitalisation and state capacity. A panel of experts from research, policy, and industry discussed how governments can capture the potential benefits of cashless payments for service delivery and fiscal visibility without undermining financial inclusion or deterring tax compliance.

Cashless payments and state capacity

Following an introduction from ICTD Research Affiliate Lúcia Rossel, Santoro gave a preview of the Centre’s upcoming Cashless Payments and Tax Playbook, which distils six years of ICTD research on cashless payments, tax administration, and tax policy for policymakers at the front lines of digital payments adoption.

Governments across Africa are using cashless payment data to improve tax compliance, and evidence from Eswatini, Senegal, and Rwanda has begun to show a link between digital payment of taxes and increased compliance. At the same time, survey data across six African countries shows small business owners continuing to rely on cash or personal mobile money wallets for business transactions as a way to keep off the tax agency’s radar.

“Tax administrations and governments should … offer a package of multiple, accessible services.” – Fabrizio Santoro, ICTD Research Fellow and Co-Lead, DPI and Tax programme.

To tackle this, Santoro argued that governments should offer a package of options, including fiscal incentives for both businesses and individual taxpayers. Sabine Mensah, Deputy CEO at AfricaNenda, an inclusive digital payments NGO, added that governments must leverage the payment infrastructure as an asset, and offer tools that go beyond basic payment transfers – so to make the case so compelling for merchants that they would gladly pay more taxes and get more value in return from cashless payments.

The central challenge: avoiding disincentives

When taxpayers become aware that their tax data is being used by government for other purposes – or when they face new costs arising from visibility – many revert back to using cash. Sridhar Ganapathy, Principal, Technology and Innovation at Artha Global, reflected on this challenge during India’s successful UPI rollout, where unexpected tax notices led to merchants reverting to cash use. A tiered registration and compliance scheme, as well as the gradual rollout of merchant fees over time, have helped to minimise this impact.

Davendra Damle, Head of Policy, Governance and Strategy at the Indonesian Open Network for Digital Commerce, also reflected on the potential unintended consequences of greater visibility for merchants, including scrutiny from other regulators. Open transaction networks, he argued, keep transaction data under merchant control, empowering merchants and allowing them to selectively share records to access benefits like credit.

The link between financial and digital inclusion

Kamal Andiwal, Director, Fiscal and Economic Policy Advocacy at GSMA, drew a link between financial inclusion and the connectivity gap: the number of people not connected to mobile internet.

According to GSMA research, at least 690 million Africans living within mobile network coverage do not use mobile internet, due to lack of access to a smartphone or the high cost of data – sometimes magnified by taxes on devices. This leaves them unable to make cashless payments, whether to businesses or for payment of taxes.

Policy responses have been met with differing levels of success. GSMA research finds that, in South Africa, the exemption of entry-level smartphones from a luxury goods tax has led to an increase in uptake. In Ghana, meanwhile, the ‘e-levy’ on mobile money transactions led to an immediate 30 per cent drop in mobile money use.

Continuing the conversation

Kalpana Kochar, Interim President, Global Policy & Advocacy at Gates Foundation, closed the discussion by presenting a simple test for new cashless and DPI systems: do they create enough value, fairness and confidence that citizens choose to use them.

 “No single institution can do it by itself. No single country has all the answers. And that’s why research, peer learning, all of that is what we need.” – Kalpana Kochar, Interim President, Global Policy & Advocacy at Gates Foundation.

The panel was followed by questions from the assembled audience of researchers, administrators and officials, ranging from the communication of new obligations to citizens, tax levy design, and the potential for tiered compliance structures.

Watch the recording

 

The ICTD Cashless Payments and Tax Playbook will be published in early 2027. View this page to learn more about our work on digital payments or sign up to our Newsletter to keep updated with our latest research.

Article Details

Date

Image credit

© ICTD

Share

More resources

Related Posts

Experts