Opinion & Analysis

Digital public infrastructure, digital payments and tax compliance: Lessons from Colombia’s Bre-B

This article is also available in French

Close up on a hand holding a mobile phone displaying the Bre-B logo with a number of banknotes displayed behind the phone.

Authors

Two assumptions dominate discussions of digital public infrastructure (DPI) usage particularly when it comes to digital payments. The first is that people avoid these technologies to stay outside state oversight. The second is that uptake is mostly a matter of digital literacy. Concerns about tax reporting and illegal activity, alongside assumptions about limited formal education, often underpin these views. They are reinforced by the widely promoted potential of digital payments to close gaps in tax collection and extend the reach of tax authorities.

However, Colombia’s Bre-B system shows a more complex picture. Bre-B is a DPI-type payment system developed by Colombia’s central bank (Banco de la República). Its adoption illustrates a more nuanced and multidimensional dynamic, shaped not only by considerations of tax avoidance or digital literacy, but also by the social and cultural contexts in which technology is used.

In short, DPI usage is a social process. Revenue authorities, merchants, customers and industry participants all interact to determine which payment alternatives are used, and on what basis. Drawing on the actor-network theory lens that has been relatively underused in DPI research, a forthcoming study at the Institute of Development Studies asks: what explains digital payment usage patterns among small businesses and their customers?

The research used a qualitative approach across three cities and four rural villages. It included 35 in-depth interviews with merchants, customers and key informants including accountants and a member of Banco de la República. It also monitored 150 payments across 11 businesses including bakeries, hardware stores, restaurants, home appliance stores, pharmacies and clothing shops.

Digital payments are shaped by culture, trust and social relationships

A useful starting point for understanding the adoption and use of digital payment systems is the materiality of money. Throughout history, money has functioned not only as a tool for trade, a store of value, or a commodity, but also as a social relation and a cultural anchor. Money shapes how we interact with others and the terms of those interactions. It is, fundamentally, a form of social communication that can take various material forms, depending on the context.

DPI-type technologies and digital payment methods more broadly enter a context in which different meanings of money are already embedded and contested through financial inclusion projects. The lightness and convenience of digital money can generate significant benefits. Yet, for some communities in developing economies, this same intangibility can feel uncomfortable, untrustworthy or even threatening to the opportunities and benefits that physical money can provide. This was evident among rural merchants in Colombia’s coffee-growing region, who described money in interviews as something to be “felt,” “carried” and “worked.”

This is an often-overlooked dimension of discussions about DPI and digital payments: the cultural and contextual place of money. One reason may be that DPI design has often paid insufficient attention to the communities in which these technologies are intended to operate. Indeed, governments have focused considerably on public–private partnerships and the development of interoperable systems, but far less on incorporating people’s lived experiences of money and technology into the design.

This gap is visible, for example, in the development of Bre-B, where multiple stakeholders were involved in developing the system, but its intended users were largely absent from the process. This might explain why, despite an initial high uptake – with 35 million people registering in the first 10 months, in a country of approximately 54 million people – the vast majority of all transactions (78%) remain cash-based.

DPI may improve tax traceability or reduce illicit financial activity, yet, these benefits cannot be considered in isolation from the cultural and social dimensions of money and technology, or from the uneven effects that digitalisation can have across different populations. Without this perspective, DPI is unlikely to significantly enhance state capacity, improve tax collection and control illegal economies.

Digital literacy does not explain how people use digital payments

A second layer to unpack is the role of digital literacy in lower- and middle-income countries particularly across Latin America, Africa and South Asia.

Technology availability and adoption do not necessarily equate to meaningful use. In turn, use does not necessarily equate to intended use. Indeed, everyday technology usage is complex, shaped by factors like education, age, gender, and life trajectory. While the adoption of digital tools may require a form of human infrastructure – namely people’s capacity to use, understand and learn digital tools – expanding access to financial education does not automatically lead to greater adoption of digital financial technologies. This is particularly true because money remains a private and sensitive topic, often shaped by gendered relationships and the division of responsibilities. Learning about financial technologies, therefore, depends not only on the technical capacity, but also on trust, privacy and shared understanding. The same applies to DPI systems, which rely on forms of data that many users are hesitant to share.

In practice, systems such as Bre-B can spread through networks of kinship and trust rather than through formal programmes of education or literacy. Technology adoption is frequently framed in terms of incentives and efficiency gains, but this explanation alone overlooks the importance of meaning and social interaction in shaping how technologies are used.

The distinction is therefore not simply between “adoption” and “non-adoption”. Users adapt technologies to their own circumstances, relationships and priorities. Digital payments, perhaps more than any other form of digital infrastructure, depend on these social drivers to fulfil their goals.

Digital public infrastructure and the promise of greater tax compliance

The dynamics previously highlighted also have important implications for tax collection.

It is often assumed that individuals who resist digital payments are primarily seeking to avoid taxation. Yet our research found that merchants often want to file and pay their taxes. Compliance can be seen as a way of improving their standing as taxpayers and strengthening their profile as credit-seekers, possibly leading to other future benefits. At the same time, merchants widely expressed concerns about the complexity of tax compliance. Many informants noted that managing tax obligations typically requires the support of an accountant, with this realisation often coming only after penalties have been incurred for late payment. This reflects not only the administrative burden of compliance but also limited trust in both tax authorities and intermediaries as merchants are often reluctant to share detailed financial information. The costs of professional support, alongside liabilities and penalties, can consequently discourage engagement.

What this means for the future of digital public infrastructure

These findings point to new directions for research on DPI and taxation. Future work should examine how communities adopt and adapt DPI systems at the micro level, as well as how these systems mediate relationships among individuals, states, businesses and platforms.

Public policy would benefit from deeper engagement with the social dynamics of DPI. Policymakers and researchers alike should pay greater attention to how these systems are embedded in everyday life and how users understand and relate to taxation, money and technology. Co-design approaches could support this work by incorporating communities’ perceptions, needs and practices into DPI development. Understanding these perspectives from the outset could help ensure that systems are not only technically interoperable, but also socially relevant and responsive to the contexts in which they are used.

A key takeaway is that tax digitalisation is not a standalone development challenge. It is closely tied to how people integrate money and technology into their social lives. The design of DPI systems is therefore central to achieving the public financial management goals associated with digitalisation. This requires moving beyond a narrow focus on compliance, avoidance and digital literacy. It means recognising the role of community, social learning existing tax payment practices and technology-enabled connectivity in shaping how DPI is used and ultimately, what it can achieve.

Disclaimer: The views expressed in this opinion piece are those of the author/s and do not necessarily reflect the views or policies of ICTD or any of its funders.

Article Details

Date

Share

More resources

Related Posts